Customer Service Staff

We want you to have the best insurance possible!

At Key Agency, Inc., our dedicated team strives to deliver the insurance solutions that best suit your needs, all at the most competitive rates. We’re committed to ensuring you receive maximum coverage for what matters most. Reach out to your customer service representative today via email or phone if you require any assistance or have inquiries.


Owners


David Dignam

David Dignam, Owner, Agent

President
Brandon Dignam

Brandon Dignam, Owner, Agent

Vice President
Brandon@keyagency.net
Eric Fogo

Eric Fogo, Owner, Agent

Executive Vice President - Retired

Administration

Sue Joachim

Sue Joachim, Office Manager, CSR

941-460-1228
Englewood Office
Sue@keyagency.net
Sheryl Downing

Sheryl Downing, Administrative Assistant

941-460-1296
Englewood Office
Sheryl@keyagency.net
Debra Konik

Debra Konik, Personal Lines Supervisor, CSR

941-460-1215 / 941-460-1216
Englewood & North Port Offices
Debra@keyagency.net
Beth Tubbesing

Beth Tubbesing, Commercial Lines Supervisor, Agent

941-460-1295
Englewood Office
Beth@keyagency.net
Cindy Lewis

Cindy Lewis, Claims Agent

941-460-1212
Englewood Office
Cindy@keyagency.net
Janae Boyer

Janae Boyer, Receptionist, Admin Support, CSR

941-460-1231
Englewood Office
Janae@keyagency.net
Jenna Warner

Jenna Warner, Receptionist

941-460-1201
Englewood Office
Jenna@keyagency.net

Personal Insurance

Taylor Edwards

Taylor Edwards, Owner, Agent

941-460-1238
Englewood Office
TaylorEdwards@keyagency.net
Jennifer Krejci

Jennifer Krejci, Agent, Builder & Realtor Concierge

941-460-1229
Englewood Office
Jennifer@keyagency.net
Janine Livesey

Janine Livesey, Agent

941-460-1202
Boca Grande Office
Janine@keyagency.net
Tyler Treasure

Tyler Treasure, Agent

941-460-1289
Wellen Park Office
Tyler@keyagency.net
Hailey Anderson

Hailey Anderson, CSR

941-460-1237
Englewood Office
Hailey@keyagency.net
Nicole Campbell

Nicole Campbell, Agent

941-460-1222
Englewood Office
Nicole@keyagency.net
Kristin Crook

Kristin Crook, CSR

941-460-1285
Englewood Office
KCrook@keyagency.net
Susan Deramo

Susan Deramo, Agent

941-460-1272
Englewood Office
SusanDeramo@keyagency.net
Sandra Hayes

Sandra Hayes, CSR

941-460-1286
Englewood Office
Sandra@keyagency.net
Missy Johnivan

Missy Johnivan, Agent

941-460-1205
Englewood Office
Missy@keyagency.net
Mike Lampros

Mike Lampros, Agent

941-460-1224
Englewood Office
Mike@keyagency.net
Sarah Murtaugh

Sarah Murtaugh, CSR

941-460-1232
Englewood Office
Sarah@keyagency.net
Bri Reigle

Bri Reigle, CSR

941-460-1213
Englewood Office
Bri@keyagency.net
Gail Strosnider

Gail Strosnider, CSR

941-460-1245
Englewood Office
Gail@keyagency.net
Tina Watson

Tina Watson, CSR

941-460-1226
Englewood Office
Tina@keyagency.net
Laurie Wetzler

Laurie Wetzler, Agent

941-460-1217
Englewood Office
Laurie@keyagency.net
Taylor Wood

Taylor Wood, Agent

941-460-1203
Englewood Office
Taylor@keyagency.net
Susan Miller

Susan Miller, Processor

941-460-1221
Englewood Office
SusanM@keyagency.net
Lexi Negrich

Lexi Negrich, Training Processor

941-460-1206
Englewood Office
Lexi@keyagency.net
Kristine Riley

Kristine Riley, Processor

941-460-1239
Englewood Office
Kristine@keyagency.net
Lynn Willobee

Lynn Willobee, Processor, CSR

941-460-1234
Englewood Office
Lynn@keyagency.net
Ameera Mitchell

Ameera Mitchell, Agent

941-460-1287
North Port Office
Ameera@keyagency.net
Kim Nichols

Kim Nichols, Agent

941-460-1283
North Port Office
Kim@keyagency.net
Becca Reagin

Becca Reagin, CSR

941-460-1223
North Port Office
Becca@keyagency.net
Jodi Selph

Jodi Selph, CSR

941-460-1282
North Port Office
JodiS@keyagency.net
Cindy Brady

Cindy Brady, Receptionist

941-460-1281
North Port Office
CindyBrady@keyagency.net
Nancy Ditsche

Nancy Ditsche, Receptionist, CSR

941-460-1214
North Port Office
Nancy@keyagency.net
Kelly Maris

Kelly Maris, Processor

941-460-1279
North Port Office
Kelly@keyagency.net

Commercial Insurance

Austin Fogo

Austin Fogo, Owner, Producer

941-460-1297
Englewood Office
Austin@keyagency.net
Brian Blankenbaker

Brian Blankenbaker, CSR

941-460-1233
Englewood Office
BrianB@keyagency.net
Lisa Brumbaugh

Lisa Brumbaugh, Agent

941-460-1218
Englewood Office
Lisa@keyagency.net
Jeff Eldredge

Jeff Eldredge, CSR

941-460-1227
Englewood Office
Jeff@keyagency.net
Kandie Fogo

Kandie Fogo, Agent

941-460-1288
Englewood Office
Kandie@keyagency.net
Ann Foster-Speid

Ann Foster-Speid, CSR

941-460-1211
Englewood Office
Ann@keyagency.net
Pat Lathrop

Pat Lathrop, Processor

941-460-1219
Englewood Office
Pat@keyagency.net
Theresa Reynolds

Theresa Reynolds, Agent

941-460-1248
Englewood Office
Theresa@keyagency.net
Sarah Wetzler

Sarah Wetzler, Agent

941-460-1204
Englewood Office
SarahW@keyagency.net
Lyn Eastman

Lyn Eastman, Agent

941-460-1243
North Port Office
LynEastman@keyagency.net
Richard Schmith

Richard Schmith, Producer, Agent

941-460-1284
North Port Office
Rich@keyagency.net
Krystal Stephens

Krystal Stephens, Agent

941-460-1290
North Port Office
Krystal@keyagency.net